Skip to main content

This is a sample report for a fictional company. Get your own in about 5 minutes.

Get my free report

Audit report for

Cascade Dental Group (sample)

Top things to know

A plain-English read on what stood out in your answers.

Overall, your benefits program is showing significant risk signals — most notably around renewal timing.

  • Your renewal is in about 41 days

    Most brokers benchmark 60–90 days out. This is the window where alternatives can still be quoted.

  • Your renewal is running ahead of peers your size

    Your last increase was about 11%. Employers your size are seeing closer to 9%, so you are running roughly 2 points ahead of the market. That works out to roughly $68,640 per year in added employer cost.

  • There are gaps in the service you're getting

    Based on what you reported about benchmarking cadence, options shown at renewal, and year-round communication, a few service touchpoints most employers your size receive aren't happening. A second-opinion review can confirm whether that gap is real.

  • You may be a strong fit for Captive / shared risk pool or MERP (Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan)

    Based on your size, funding type, and claims signals, you fall in the range where alternative funding strategies often outperform a traditional fully-insured plan. Worth modeling side-by-side at your next renewal.

Overall Benefit Score

Higher means a healthier benefits strategy. Educational only.

54/100

Estimated dollar impact

Based on the spend and renewal increase you entered. Directional only.

Annualized employer spend

$624,000

Added cost from ~11% increase

$68,640

Vs. peers your size (~9%)

+$12,480/yr

Total spend vs. peers your size

Compares your employer-paid premium per employee on payroll to typical employers in 50–199 employees. Peer figure blends KFF 2025 single and family averages and assumes about 57% of headcount enrolls, which is typical at your size.

Your employer spend / employee / mo

$612

Peer benchmark (50–199 employees)

$620/mo

Vs. peers (annualized)

−$8,160/yr

How you compare to peers

Directional benchmarks for 50–199 employees. Sources: KFF, SHRM, MetLife — see footer.

Dental

You: Offer · Peers: ~85% offer

On par

Vision

You: Offer · Peers: ~79% offer

On par

Life

You: Offer · Peers: ~77% offer

On par

Disability

You: Don't offer · Peers: ~68% offer

Gap

HSA / FSA

You: Don't offer · Peers: ~64% offer

Gap

Group health

You: Offer · Peers: ~90% offer

On par

Voluntary benefits

You offer: Accident.

Accident

~38% of employers with fewer than 500 workers offer it

You offer this

70% of employees with access say they enroll

Critical Illness

~17% of employers with fewer than 500 workers offer it

Not offered

53% of employees with access say they enroll

Hospital Indemnity

~15% of employers with fewer than 500 workers offer it

Not offered

61% of employees with access say they enroll

For you

Voluntary benefits let you offer employees additional financial protection without committing to pay the premiums. Your employees choose what they want and pay for what they elect. You gain a richer benefit package without being exposed to additional risk.

For your employees

Employees can purchase additional coverage that pays money directly to them for illnesses, injuries, ER visits, and hospital stays. They choose the coverage that matters to them and only pay premium if enrolled.

Only 11% of employers offer all three core lines. Employer offer rates: 2025 national survey of 408 employers (counts any offering, regardless of who pays). Take-up: 2026 national employee survey, self-reported among those with access — not a forecast for a new group.

Funding mix vs. peers your size

How employers in the 51–99 employees band typically fund their health plans. Directional industry estimates only.

Fully insured

35–50%

You

Level-funded

30–40%

Self-funded

15–25%

ICHRA

2–5%

PEO

5–10%

Many healthier groups migrate from fully insured to level-funded around this size.

You're in the size band where 30–40% of peers have moved to level-funded and 15–25% are self-funded. Worth knowing what's available before your next renewal.

Plan design snapshot

Based on the plan details you entered. Educational only — your broker can confirm specifics.

Plan type

PPO

Plan options offered

1

Only one plan option limits employee choice — peers usually offer 2–3.

Individual deductible

$3,000

Mid-range — common but worth checking against employee feedback.

Family deductible

$6,000

Employee-only monthly premium

$780

Family monthly premium

$2,150

Employer contribution

75%

In line with or above peer norms.

Loss ratio snapshot

Loss ratio = annual claims paid ÷ annual premium paid. Over 85% means the carrier is likely to push for a renewal increase.

Ask your broker for a claims experience report

At your size, your carrier almost certainly tracks how much you pay in premium vs. how much they pay out in claims (your 'loss ratio'). If it's running over 85%, your renewal will likely jump. Request the report — most brokers can pull it in a day.

Alternative funding fit

Directional fit only — actual suitability depends on quotes, underwriting, and a licensed advisor's review.

Level-funded

possible fit

Acts like a fully-insured plan day-to-day, but if claims come in low you may get a partial refund at year end. A common first step for groups exploring alternatives.

Requires medical underwriting; not every group will qualify.

Self-funded

possible fit

You pay claims directly (with stop-loss insurance for catastrophic claims) instead of paying a fixed premium. Real upside if claims experience is good — real downside if it's not.

Requires comfort with month-to-month variability and a broker/TPA who specializes in self-funded plans.

Captive / shared risk pool

strong fit

Multiple mid-market employers pool risk together. Good claims years stay with the group rather than the carrier, and you get more transparency into your spend.

Multi-year commitment; best fit when claims experience is healthy and you want to act more like an asset owner.

ICHRA

possible fit

You give employees a tax-advantaged allowance to buy individual coverage on their own. Strong fit when employees are spread across multiple states or want more plan choice.

Shifts plan selection to employees; ACA affordability rules still apply.

MERP (Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan)

strong fit

Raise the deductible on a fully insured plan to lower premium, then reimburse employees for part of the deductible gap. Net cost usually drops while the employee experience stays similar.

Employer front-funds reimbursements; works best when you have cash flow comfort and a stable claims pattern.

HRA (Health Reimbursement Arrangement)

strong fit

Employer-funded account that reimburses qualified medical expenses. Pairs well with higher-deductible plans and gives a recruiting / retention talking point without the long-term cost of richer plan design.

Funds don't roll to the employee — unused dollars typically stay with the employer at year end.

PEO (Professional Employer Organization)

possible fit

Bundles benefits, payroll, and HR/compliance under one master plan. Often gives small groups access to richer benefits than they could buy standalone.

Less plan flexibility and harder to unwind than a broker-led arrangement — usually a better fit under ~150 employees.

Programs you may qualify for

Based on your location, size and answers.

Petra Community Care

Strong match

Petra Community Care is a partially self-funded medical program for mid-sized employers, associated with Alliant's Idaho team. It coordinates how healthcare is purchased to help manage medical spending. Its pharmacy program, PetraRx, is also available on its own.

Why you're seeing this

Based in Washington · 85 employees · 11% renewal increase · Rising costs are a top concern

What to know

  • With partial self-funding, your company pays employees' covered claims, and stop-loss insurance protects you from very large claims.
  • You may need cash set aside beyond your monthly budget for deposits or timing gaps.
  • Savings depend on your claims and the actual contract terms — results vary and nothing here is a guarantee.

What you'd need for a quote

  • Eligible and enrolled employee counts, by coverage tier
  • Current carrier, plan designs and rates
  • Your renewal date
  • 24–36 months of medical and pharmacy claims history, if you have it

Eligibility is decided by the program's underwriting. Availability and terms still need to be confirmed with an advisor.

Fully-insured cost-containment playbook

Levers worth reviewing before you accept your renewal, ranked by relevance to your answers. Educational only.

  1. 1

    Employee education and telemedicine

    Industry estimates suggest up to 18% of plan spend is tied to how well employees understand and use their benefits — employee understanding of benefits scored low and telemedicine isn't offered today. Adding telemedicine and a structured open-enrollment education push is one of the cheapest cost-containment moves available.

  2. 2

    Optimize plan design

    Reviewing deductibles, out-of-pocket maxes, and copay structure side-by-side is the cheapest lever — small design tweaks can move premium meaningfully without changing carriers.

  3. 3

    Adjust employer contribution

    You're covering about 75% of the premium — above the typical ~75% benchmark for employee-only. A small shift in contribution can offset a meaningful chunk of a renewal increase.

    Trade-off: Disruptive to retention if done aggressively — pair with employee communication and a smaller plan-design change.

  4. 4

    Reframe ancillary lines as retention, not cost

    You're missing 1 ancillary line (of dental/vision/life/disability). Voluntary options carry no employer cost and create a perceived-value bump employees feel at every paycheck — often a better recruiting lever than a contribution increase.

Employee benefits education

Self-reported: 2/5

Employee benefits literacy looks low

Industry estimates suggest up to 18% of plan spend is tied to how well employees understand and use their benefits — 20% of employees typically drive ~80% of claims. Structured open-enrollment education + year-round nudges is one of the cheapest cost-containment levers available.

Cost Risk

High

How exposed your company is to rising premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket cost trends.

Your cost risk appears elevated based on your renewal increase and reported cost concerns. It may be worth reviewing contribution strategy, plan design, and alternative funding options with a licensed advisor.

What's driving this score

  • Renewal increase of ~11%
  • You flagged the plan as too expensive
Questions worth asking
  • What's driving our increase — claims experience, age band, or general trend?
  • What level-funded or alternative-funded options would fit a company our size?
  • How does our employer-vs-employee contribution split compare to peers?

Renewal Urgency

Very High

How much runway you have before you're locked into another plan year.

Your renewal is roughly 41 days out, which means now is a good time to review options before defaulting into another plan year.

What's driving this score

  • Renewal in ~41 days
Questions worth asking
  • What's the latest date we can request alternative quotes for this renewal?
  • Can you put together a side-by-side of 3 plan designs at our current carrier?
  • Which carriers are realistic alternatives for our size and state?

Benefits Competitiveness

Moderate

How your benefits package stacks up against peer employers your size.

Your benefits package covers most of the common lines we look at. Continued benchmarking against peer employers is still worth reviewing.

What's driving this score

  • No disability offered
Questions worth asking
  • What ancillary lines (dental, vision, life, disability) make sense at our size?
  • What's the typical employer cost of adding voluntary vs. employer-paid lines?
  • Which add-ons have the biggest perceived value per dollar for employees?

Employee Retention Risk

Moderate

How likely benefits are to be a factor in employees leaving — or candidates not joining.

Retention risk based on benefits appears moderate to low. Continued employee feedback is still worth reviewing.

What's driving this score

  • Mixed employee feedback on benefits
  • Benefits rated very important for retention
Questions worth asking
  • Have you done an employee survey on benefits satisfaction recently?
  • What benefits do peer employers in our industry add to retain mid-career talent?
  • Could a small contribution increase + plan design tweak move retention?

Service & Advocacy

High

Whether the day-to-day service experience — benchmarking cadence, options shown at renewal, year-round communication — matches what employers your size typically receive.

Your broker support score appears low because of limited benchmarking and limited proactive communication. You may benefit from a second-opinion review.

What's driving this score

  • Broker doesn't benchmark your plan
  • Broker doesn't present alternatives
Questions worth asking
  • Can you walk me through how you benchmarked our plan this year?
  • How many alternative quotes did you market this renewal?
  • What's your communication cadence outside of renewal season?

Alternative Strategy Fit

Very High

Whether non-traditional approaches (ICHRA, level-funded, PEO) are worth a serious look.

Based on your company size and cost concerns, it may be worth reviewing options such as SHOP, ICHRA, level-funded plans, PEO options, or ancillary benefit adjustments. Actual suitability depends on your location, employee census, contribution strategy, and carrier availability.

What's driving this score

  • Renewal increase of ~11% suggests reviewing alternatives
  • 85 employees opens more funding options
Questions worth asking
  • Have we ever evaluated ICHRA, level-funded, SHOP, or PEO for our situation?
  • What would it take to model one of those side-by-side with our current plan?
  • What's the realistic downside or risk of each alternative for our size?

Tax Credit / Program Fit

Low

Whether your size and contribution profile may make small-employer programs worth checking.

Tax credit / SHOP fit appears less likely at your size, but a qualified advisor or tax professional can confirm.

What's driving this score

  • Employer pays 50%+ of premium
Questions worth asking
  • Are we in a band where the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit could apply?
  • Should we be evaluating SHOP for any of these reasons?
  • Who on your team or your CPA partner can confirm eligibility?

Recommended next steps

  • Review your renewal at least 90 days before your effective date.
  • Ask your broker for a side-by-side comparison of 3 plan options.
  • Survey employees before changing plan design.
  • Compare employer contribution strategies and plan design alternatives.
  • Explore alternative funding such as level-funded, ICHRA, SHOP, or PEO with a licensed advisor.
  • Schedule a second-opinion benefits review with a licensed advisor.

Play with the numbers

Three scenarios you can test against your own spend: what a renewal increase costs you, what happens if you shift the employer/employee split, and what growth adds. Everything runs in your browser — nothing is saved, and none of it changes your Benefit Score.

$
Your number
From your audit

Changing your employee count keeps your monthly total unchanged and resets the growth scenario to your current count.

This is the total monthly premium your business pays across all enrolled employees — the check you write, not the employee payroll deductions. It works out to $612/employee/month across 85 total employees, and it drives every figure in all three tabs below.

Based on the premium you gave us in your plan details. Edit it here to test other scenarios — changes here are temporary and won't alter your saved report.

11%
0%Peers your size: ~9%30%

Drag to a renewal percentage and see what it costs you. The solid bars are your spend at that rate; the faded bars are what employers your size typically absorb.

Employer annual spend, next year

$692,906

Your $624,240 a year today, increased by 11%

Added employer cost vs. today

+$68,666

Per year — above the ~9% peers your size typically see

Added cost per employee / month

+$67

The same increase, broken down per employee

At a steady 11%, your benefits spend roughly doubles in about 7 years. The faded bars show what the same years look like at the ~9% typical for 50–199 employees.

Every dollar figure here is employer-paid unless a label says otherwise. These are directional estimates for planning conversations — not quotes, and not a guarantee of future premiums. Actual renewals depend on claims experience, carrier, plan design, geography, and underwriting.

Want a second opinion on these findings?

A licensed benefits advisor can walk through your report with you and answer questions. No quote pressure, no obligation to change anything.

How's your compliance housekeeping?

Cost is one side of the picture. Take the free 3-minute Compliance Quick-Check — plan documents, eligibility rules, COBRA, and more — and get a Compliance Score with the gaps worth reviewing.

Take the Compliance Quick-Check

Benchmark sources: KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey, SHRM Employee Benefits Survey, MetLife EBTS. Figures are directional and may not reflect your specific industry, region, or carrier mix. Scoring engine v1 · benchmark dataset v2 (2025 survey year (published Oct 2025), 2026 renewal filings). Read the full methodology.